Pos Rank | POS | Name | Class | School Name City & State | College Choice |
| | PG | Tyree Graham | 2010 JUCO | Brunswick CC Brunswick, NC | Rutgers |
| | WG | Muhamed Hasani | 2010 | KB Sigal Prisina, KO | Rutgers |
| | WF | Mike Poole | 2010 | St. Benedict's Newark, NJ | Rutgers |
| 11 | WG / PG | Michael Rosario | 2008 | St. Anthony's Jersey City, NJ | Rutgers |
| 30 | PF / C | Christian Morris | 2008 | South Kent School South Kent, CT | Rutgers |
| | C / PF | Greg Echenique | 2008 | St. Benedict's (NJ) Newark, NJ | Rutgers |
| | WF | Patrick Jackson | 2008 | Boys & Girls Brooklyn, NY | Rutgers |
| | PG | James Beatty | 2009 JUCO | Miami Dade Miami, FL | Rutgers |
| | PF / WF | Austin Johnson | 2009 | Blair Acdemy Blairstown, NJ | Rutgers |
| | WF | Dane Miller | 2009 | Rush-Henrietta Henrietta, NY | Rutgers |
| | C | Brian Okam | 2009 | Lake Highland Orlando, FL | Rutgers |
| | PF | Gil Biruta | 2010 | St. Benedict's Newark, NJ | Rutgers |
| | PG / WG | Austin Carroll | 2010 | Brewster Academy Wolfeboro, NH | Rutgers |
| | PG / WG | Maiscei Grier | 2011 | Arbor View Las Vegas, NV | Rutgers |
| | WF | Andrew Nicholas | 2011 | Eastern York Wrightsville, PA | Rutgers |
| | PF / WF | Jordan Goodman | 2012 | Progressive Christian Temple Hills, MD | Rutgers |
| 1 | PF / C | Samardo Samuels | 2008 | St. Benedict's Newark, NJ | Louisville |
| 4 | PF / WF | Devin Ebanks | 2008 | St. Thomas More Oakdale, CT | West Virginia |
| 5 | WF | Mookie Jones | 2008 | Peekskill Peekskill, NY | Syracuse |
| 12 | PF | Kevin Jones | 2008 | Mt. Vernon Mt. Vernon, NY | West Virginia |
| 22 | PF | Quintrell Thomas | 2008 | St. Patrick's Elizabeth, NJ | Kansas |
| 27 | PG / WG | Travon Woodall | 2008 | St. Anthony's Jersey City, NJ | Pittsburgh |
| 28 | WG | Jarrett Mann | 2008 | Blair Academy Blairstown, NJ | Stanford |
| | PF | Bilal Dixon | 2008 | Queen of Peace North Arlington, NJ | Providence |
| | PG / PG | Trinity Fields | 2008 | Cardozo Bayside, NY | |
| | WG / PG | Ashton Gibbs | 2008 | Seton Hall Prep West Orange, NJ | Pittsburgh |
| | WF / PF | Anthony King | 2008 | Roman Catholic Philadelphia, PA | |
| | PF | Dwight Miller | 2008 | Pius X Houston, TX | Pittsburgh |
| | PF | Ryan Pearson | 2008 | Christ the King Middle Village, NY | George Mason |
| | PF | Kevin Phillip | 2008 | Bishop Loughlin Brooklyn, NY | Drexel |
| | PG | Dwan Robinson | 2008 | St. Benedict's Newark, NJ | |
| | PG | Zach Rosen | 2008 | St. Benedict's Newark, NJ | Pennsylvania |
| | PF / C | Mitchell Watt | 2008 | Desert Edge Goodyear, AZ | Buffalo |
| | WG / PG | Antoine Allen | 2009 | Elite Christian Jackson, MS | Miami (FL) |
| | PF | Isaiah Armwood | 2009 | Montrose Christian Rockville, MD | Villanova |
| | WF | Tevin Baskin | 2009 | Trinity Christian Stamford, CT | Quinnipiac |
| | C | David Bruce | 2009 | Linden Linden, NJ | St. Joseph's |
| | WF | Mike Burwell | 2009 | South Kent School South Kent, CT | South Florida |
| | WF | Dominic Cheek | 2009 | St. Anthony's Jersey City, NJ | Villanova |
| | PG / WG | Vincent Council | 2009 | Patterson School Lenoir, NC | Providence |
| | WF | Givon Crump | 2009 | Brewster Academy Wolfeboro, NH | Baylor |
| | PF / PF | Dan Jennings | 2009 | Oak Hill Academy Mouth of Wilson, VA | West Virginia |
| | WG / PG | Lamont Jones | 2009 | Oak Hill Academy Mouth of Wilson, VA | Arizona |
| | WG | Thomas Manzano | 2009 JUCO | Garden City CC Garden City, KS | Wyoming |
| | WF | Brian Oliver | 2009 | William Penn New Castle, DE | Georgia Tech |
| | WF | Kevin Parrom | 2009 | South Kent School South Kent, CT | Arizona |
| | WF / PF | Dalton Pepper | 2009 | Fairless Hills Pennsbury, PA | West Virginia |
| | C | Brett Roseboro | 2009 | Quakertown Quakertown, PA | Marquette |
| | PG | Malik Stith | 2009 | Bridgton Academy (ME) North Bridgton, ME | St. John's |
| | WG | Dexter Strickland | 2009 | St. Patrick's Elizabeth, NJ | North Carolina |
| | PG / WG | Bryon Allen | 2010 | St. Thomas More Oakdale, CT | George Mason |
| | PG | Billy Baron | 2010 | Worcester Academy Worcester, MA | Virginia |
| | PG | Chris Denson | 2010 | Shaw Columbus, GA | Auburn |
| | WF | Fuquan Edwin | 2010 | Catholic Paterson, NJ | |
| | PG | Tyrone Garland | 2010 | Bartram Philadelphia, PA | Virginia Tech |
| | PG | Dwan McMillan | 2010 JUCO | Miami Dade Miami, FL | |
| | WF | J.J. Moore | 2010 | South Kent School South Kent, CT | Pittsburgh |
| | WF / WG | Jesse Morgan | 2010 | South Kent School South Kent , CT | Seton Hall |
| | PF | Rod Odom | 2010 | Middlesex Concord, MA | Vanderbilt |
| | PG | Travis Payton | 2010 JUCO | Central Arizona CC Coolidge, AZ | Texas San Antonio |
| | PF / WF | Jayvaughn Pinkston | 2010 | Bishop Loughlin Brooklyn, NY | Villanova |
| | WF | Shaquille Thomas | 2010 | Mountain State Academy Beckley, WV | |
| | WF / PF | D. J. Wright | 2010 | Salt Lake CC Salt Lake, UT | Louisiana Tech |
| | WF | Michael Gilchrist | 2011 | St. Patrick's Elizabeth, NJ | Kentucky |
| | WG | Derrick Gordon | 2011 | St. Patrick's Elizabeth, NJ | Western Kentucky |
| | PG / WG | Ge-Lawn Guyn | 2011 | Brewster Academy Wolfeboro, NH | Cincinnati |
| | PF | Desmond Hubert | 2011 | New Egypt New Egypt, NJ | |
| | PG | Tyrone Johnson | 2011 | Plainfield Plainfield, NJ | Villanova |
| | PG | Myck Kabongo | 2011 | Findlay Prep Henderson, NV | Texas |
| | PF | Eric Katenda | 2011 | Cheshire Academy Cheshire, CT | |
| | C | Markus Kennedy | 2011 | Winchendon School Winchendon, MA | Villanova |
| | PG | Myles Mack | 2011 | Catholic Paterson, NJ | |
| | WG | Mike Taylor | 2011 | Brooklyn Boys & Girls Brooklyn, NY | |
| | PG / WG | Ryan Arcidiacono | 2012 | Neshaminy Langhorne, PA | |
| | PF | Andre Drummond | 2012 | St. Thomas More Oakdale, CT | |
| | C / PF | Austin Colbert | 2013 | St. Patrick's Elizabeth, NJ | |